Question: Is objectivity the best way to know the truth about (material/physical) reality?
Write a one page essay in which you argue FOR or AGAINST the claim that objectivity is the best way to know the truth about reality.
Select one position for objectivity and one position against objectivity for this debate, e.g. Science vs. Perspectivism.
State your thesis clearly, for example, “I argue objectivity, not subjectivity, is the best way to know the truth about reality.
Briefly define “objectivity” and the oppositional position you select.
Develop only one example to illustrate & argue for your position. State the example in the form of a truth claim, e.g. “It is true that humans are causing climate change.”
Compare and contrast the two ways of getting at the truth about your example.
Make an argument for your position based on the same example.
Consider and refute your opposition’s best reply to your argument based on the same example.
Make use of the arguments in the assigned texts.
Advice on selecting an example: Select an example from a field/discipline about which you already know something. For example: If you are studying to become a teacher, the reality which you want to know the truth about is your students’ performance on assignments.
Other Examples: Claims of truth concerning…
- Climate change, poverty, or other events/situations
- Medical or psychological diagnosis
- Use of drugs, alcohol or pharmaceuticals
- Frogs, or other animals
- A verdict, e.g. O.J. is innocent
- An artistic/literary masterpiece, e.g. Mona Lisa or Moby Dick
- Student success
- Best sports team
- “True Love”
- Or, be original… and come up with your own