Problem: Provide a peer review to your classmate, Mike's summary of the article below using the below instructions. Write the peer review like it was written by me. Provide a first-person perspective.
Instructions:
Review your classmate's summary and compare to the article source. How well did the peer summarize the article in his or her own words? How well did the peer capture the key ideas from the article? How well did the peer explain how this article relates to his or her policy project? Need Assignment Help?
Article source:
"Yusuf, J., Bukvic, A., & Covi, M. (2025). Household Property-Level Adaptive Response to coastal flooding in Hampton, Virginia (USA): the role of perceived vulnerability and coping capacity. Coastal Management, 1-22.
Summary:
"The article examines how Hampton residents experience and responds to two major types of flooding-sunny-day flooding caused by high tides and storm-surge flooding from hurricanes and other extreme weather events. The study highlights that households' responses to flooding are not only shaped by the physical risk they face but also by how vulnerable they feel, their financial and social resources, and their perceived ability to cope. The authors argue that residents who see themselves as highly vulnerable and who feel they have limited coping capacity are less likely to invest in protective measures, while those who believe they can manage the risk are more inclined to take adaptive actions, such as elevating their homes, purchasing flood insurance, or installing flood barriers.
The key ideas of the article revolve around the intersection of perception, capacity, and behavior in disaster resilience. While flooding is an objective hazard, the community's adaptive responses vary widely depending on socioeconomic status, previous flood experience, and trust in government and science. For example, wealthier homeowners with access to resources are more likely to adopt costly protective measures, whereas lower-income residents often rely on temporary or minimal responses. Additionally, the article notes that misinformation or limited communication about long-term climate risks reduces the likelihood of proactive adaptation. Importantly, the study underscores that resilience is not only a matter of engineering or infrastructure but also of psychological and social dynamics-how households perceive their risk and whether they feel supported by institutions.
This article has strong implications for policy change and local community resilience. At the policy level, the findings suggest that simply providing technical solutions (such as flood maps or building codes) is not enough. Policymakers must also consider how residents understand their own vulnerability and how local governments can build trust, improve communication, and provide equitable financial support. Programs that subsidize flood insurance, offer tax incentives for home retrofits, or provide direct grants for property-level adaptation could help reduce inequalities in household responses. Furthermore, stronger community engagement strategies are needed so that residents feel included in decision-making and understand the long-term benefits of adaptation.
For the Hampton community, this means shifting from a reactive approach to a proactive one. Community workshops, neighborhood flood-preparedness programs, and partnerships with local universities could empower residents with knowledge and strategies. In addition, local leaders must ensure that vulnerable populations-such as renters, low-income families, and elderly residents-are not left behind. The article essentially shows that adaptation is not just an individual decision but a community-wide process that depends on social equity, trust, and support systems.
At the end, the article demonstrates that coastal flooding in Hampton, Virginia, is not just a physical hazard but a social and political challenge. By linking household perceptions with adaptation behaviors, the authors highlight the need for policies that combine technical solutions with social support. This approach not only strengthens resilience at the household level but also enhances the community's ability to withstand future climate-related flooding."