Problem:
Bureaucratic politics" and "organizational dynamics" are both closely defined. Both can have negative and positive impacts for analysis, as well as decision-making. Analysts and decision-makers must work together to complete the mission; the military makes it simple. The Decision makers have the final say and are, by default, in charge. This could negatively impact the mission by some people feeling marginalized, on both sides, and some of the best and most effective intelligence being held back.
One definition is how operations are conducted and the political nature of an organization, and the other is the dynamic nature of how the structure is composed within the organization. Both define an organization, but one examines the way it operates, while the other focuses on how that organization is structured. Whereas bureaucratic politics is the step-by-step progression, usually referenced with the military, to accomplish your end goal by getting people to agree with your opinion. As stated by Fingar (2011), "If something makes it all the way to the top of the bureaucratic food chain before a Cabinet officer or NSC senior director spots a glaring inconsistency, something has gone badly wrong." If the analyst had gone through the bureaucratic process and communicated with the Cabinet officer, politically, there would be more support for their judgment.
Organizational dynamics can be the way an organization conducts itself in different ways. According to the CIA 's (2009) A Tradecraft Primer: Structured Analytic Techniques for Improving Intelligence Analysis, "History has shown that foreign leaders often respond differently to events because of different cultural, organizational, or personal experiences." This can also impact world events negatively. An example would be the assumption of Battle Damage Assessment (BDA) of the Iranian nuclear site damage immediately after the U.S. bombed Iran earlier this summer. Politics again played a significant role in the judgment that was believed by many. With any BDA, there usually has to be more time to get feedback. Need Assignment Help?
Send Peers Response With Reference To This Discussion