Question: 1. a. Who is the plaintiff? What is he asking the court to do?
b. Is there a statute involved in this dispute?
c. Who won?
d. Was the jury asked to determine fact or law? How was the law stated?
2. a. Who appealed the judgment?
b. Who won the appeal?
c. What is the judge's holding?
3. a. Who appealed the judgment?
b. Who won the appeal?
c. What is the judge's holding? Actually, there are three opinions. Are they in accord?