Topic: Keeping a promise vs. maximizing good
Compensation
Suppose you're the sole executor or power-of-attorney for an estate and are responsible for carrying out the will of the deceased.
You're surprised to learn that according to the terms of the will the entire estate is to be left to a cult organization known for hate-mongering and for promoting violence and racial strife.
It's clear that far more good would be accomplished by giving the estate to an international charitable organization instead. What would you do? What should you do if you followed the principles of classic utilitarianism?
What if you followed Kant's categorical imperative? What if you applied Ross's theory of moral pluralism and prima facie duties?