Discussion Post: Cultural Appropriation
After reading the two articles and watching the video, think about the issue of cultural appropriation.
Cultural appropriation occurs when someone obtains an object, belief, practice or idea from another culture and uses it in such a way that it is insulting or damaging to the culture of origin. This encourages marginalization and disenfranchisement of that culture's people. Cultural borrowing, on the other hand, refers to the use of elements of a culture other than one's own for purposes that are not derogatory or disrespectful with regard to the culture of origin.
Of importance are the intent and the impact of the acquisition of an acquired cultural element on members of the culture of origin. Ask yourself if the acquisition is harmful, beneficial (or at least respectful), or neutral in its effect on the original culture. If it is intentionally harmful, the cultural interaction is appropriation. If it is the second or third outcome, the interaction is usually considered borrowing.
Consider these issues after you read the article about Japanese Hip Hop and how its message can be different from that of the American creators of this music genre - and as you view the video about the British sport of Cricket as played by the Trobrianders (residents of the Trobriand Islands in the South Pacific.)
1) Discuss whether these two examples of cultural interaction are appropriation or borrowing. Explain your reasoning.
2) Cite specific examples from the video (reference it by the time mark in the video) and passages in the article, identified by page number. This paper should rely on specific evidence from these two sources.
3) Consider the article by Ralph Linton, which describes the world's cultures as borrowing from one another continuously, from ancient times to the present. This begs the question, what is it that a culture "owns" if almost everything is borrowed? How does this article affect your view of cultural appropriation and cultural borrowing? What are its implications for the validity of the very idea of cultural appropriation?
Do not use any sources other than your text and those listed above unless they are approved by your instructor. As with all of your graded discussions, be concise, include a clear expository thesis statement and introductory paragraph, and avoid digressing as you write.
The response must include a reference list. Using Times New Roman 12 pnt font, double-space, one-inch margins, and APA style of writing and citations.