Are We Living in a Cave?
Constructing a Life Philosophy, 2002
Plato (427-347 b.c.) lived and taught philosophy in ancient Athens. In the following viewpoint, Plato asks his audience to imagine prisoners living in a cave. The people face a wall where shadows of various objects dance back and forth. The prisoners cannot turn their heads to discover the true nature of the shadows. Further, the prisoners cannot leave the cave to discover what the reality creating the shadows is like. Plato uses this story to illustrate his belief that we are trapped by our imperfect, subjectiveimpressions of the world. Plato believes that people too quickly accept the first appearance of things.
What people experience as reality is really a distorted reflection, or shadow, of the true reality. Plato believed that humans (in the present life) will never completely understand the world. Thus, Plato challenges his listeners to carefully use reason as a tool to examine all their beliefs.As you read, consider the following questions:
1.According to Plato, humans sometimes find it hard to face reality. Why is this?
2.What is the nature of personal growth and education? Is Plato correct in suggesting that teachers often need to push students in order for them to face the truth?
3.What does Plato tell us about first impressions and prejudice?
"Next, then," I said, "take the following parable of education and ignorance as a picture of the conditionof our nature. Imagine mankind as dwelling in an underground cave with a long entrance open to the light across the whole width of the cave; in this they have been from childhood, with necks and legs fettered, so they have to stay where they are. They cannot move their heads round because of the fetters, and theycan only look forward, but light comes to them from fire burning behind them higher up at a distance. Between the fire and the prisoners is a road above their level, and along it imagine a low wall has been built, as puppet showmen have screens in front of their people over which they work their puppets." "Isee," he said. The Bearers and Things Carried "See, then, bearers carrying along this wall all sorts of articles which they hold projecting above the wall, statues of men and other living things,1 made of stone or wood and all kinds of stuff, some of the bearersspeaking and some silent, as you might expect." "What a remarkable, image," he said, "and what remarkable prisoners!" "Just like ourselves," I said. "For, first of all, tell me this:
What do you think such people would have seenof themselves and each other except their shadows, which the fire cast on the opposite wall of the cave?" "I don't see how they could see anything else," said he, "if they were compelled to keep their heads unmoving all their lives!" "Very well, what of the things being carried along? Would not this be the same?" "Of course it would." "Suppose the prisoners were able to talk together, don't you think that when they named the shadows which they saw passing they would believe they were naming things?"2 "Necessarily." "Then f their prison had an echo from the opposite wall, whenever one of the passing bearers uttered a sound, would they not suppose that the passing shadow must be making the sound? Don't you think so?" "Indeed I do," he said. "If so," said I, "such persons ould certainly believe that there were no realities except those shadows of handmade things."3 "So it must be," said he. Removal of the Fetters"Now consider," said I, "what their release would be like, and their cure from these fetters and their folly;let us imagine whether it might naturally be something like this. One might be released, and compelledsuddenly to stand up and turn his neck round, and to walk and look towards the firelight; all this wouldhurt him, and he would be too much dazzled to see distinctly those things whose shadows he had seenbefore. What do you think he would say, if someone told him that what he saw before was foolery, butnow he saw more rightly, being a bit nearer reality, and turned towards what was a little more real? Whatif he were shown each of the passing things, and compelled by questions to answer what each one was?Don't you think he would be puzzled, and believe what he saw before was more true than what wasshown to him now?""Far more," he said.
"Then suppose he were compelled to look towards the real light, it would hurt his eyes, and he would escape by turning them away to the things which he was able to look at, and these he would believe to be clearer than what was being shown to him."
"Just so," said he.
Leaving the Cave
"Suppose, now," said I, "that someone should drag him thence by force, up the rough ascent, the steep way up, and never stop until he could drag him out into the light of the sun, would he not be distressed and furious at being dragged; and when he came into the ight, the brilliance would fill his eyes and he would not be able to see even one of the things now called real?"4"That he would not," aid he, "all of a sudden." "He would have to get used to it, surely, I think, if he is to see the things above. First he would most easily ook at shadows, after that images of mankind and the rest in water, lastly the things themselves. After this he would find it easier to survey by night the heavens themselves and all that is in them, gazingat the light of the stars and moon, rather than by day the sun and the sun's light." "Of course."
"Last of all, I suppose, the sun; he could look on the sun itself by itself in its own place, and see what it is
like, not reflections of it in water or as it appears in some alien setting."
"Necessarily," said he.
"And only after all this he might reason about it, how this is he who provides seasons and years, and is set
over all there is in the visible region, and he is in a manner the cause of all things which they saw."
"Yes, it is clear," said he, "that after all that, he would come to this last."
"Very good. Let him be reminded of his first habitation, and what was wisdom in that place, and of his
fellow-prisoners there; don't you think he would bless himself for the change, and pity them?"
"Yes, indeed."
"And if there were honours and praises among them and prizes for the one who saw the passing things
most sharply and remembered best which of them used to come before and which after and which
together, and from these was best able to prophesy accordingly what was going to come-do you believe
he would set his desire on that, and envy those who were honoured men or potentates among them?
Would he not feel as Homer says,5 and heartily desire rather to be serf of some landless man on earth and
to endure anything in the world, rather than to opine as they did and to live in that way?"
"Yes, indeed," said he, "he would rather accept anything than live like that."
Returning to the Cave
"Then again," I said, "just consider; if such a one should go down again and sit on his old seat, would he
not get his eyes full of darkness coming in suddenly out of the sun?"
"Very much so," said he.
"And if he should have to compete with those who had been always prisoners, by laying down the law
about those shadows while he was blinking before his eyes were settled down-and it would take a good
long time to get used to things-wouldn't they all laugh at him and say he had spoiled his eyesight by
going up there, and it was not worthwhile so much as to try to go up? And would they not kill anyone
who tried to release them and take them up, if they could somehow lay hands on him and kill him?"6
"That they would!" said he.
Conclusion
"Then we must apply this image, my dear Glaucon," said I, "to all we have been saying. The world of our sight is like the habitation in prison, the firelight there to the sunlight here, the ascent and the view of theupper world is the rising of the soul into the world of mind; ut it so and you will not be far from my own surmise, since that is what you want to hear; but God knows if it is really true. At least, what appears to me is, that in the world of known, last of all,7 the idea of the good, and with what toil to be seen! Andseen, this ust be inferred to be the cause of all right and beautiful things for all, which gives birth tolight and the king of light in the world of sight, nd, in the world of mind, herself the queen produces truth and reason; and she must be seen by one who is to act with reason publicly or privately."
Footnotes
1. Including models of trees, etc.
2. Which they had never seen. They would say "tree" when it was only a shadow of the model of a tree.
3. Shadows of artificial things, not even the shadow of a growing tree: another stage from reality.
4. To the next stage of knowledge: the real thing, not the artificial puppet.
5. Odyssey xi
6. Plato probably alludes to the death of Socrates. See Apology.
7. The end of our search