Problem
I. Identify the ethical issues with water rights in the Southwest border region. Identify the legal issues with water rights in this region. Is it possible to be ethical and address everyone's water rights? What economic, social, and environmental impacts would this have?
II. Has the Tule River Tribe successfully claimed its water rights? What are the impacts on this tribe? Would it be better to accommodate Native American water rights claims by giving them the rights and access to water or would it be better to compensate them monetarily (pay them for the historical and future use of their water) so that current water users can continue their activities? What would be an equitable and sustainable solution?
III. What is Minute 319? What are the economic, social, and environmental impacts of Minute 319? What are the most recent developments? Are there any new minutes addressing pulse flows?
IV. Briefly summarize the policy options to manage the water rights conflicts of the Colorado River as covered in the videos and articles in this case activity. In your opinion, what policy option is best? Briefly explain the strengths and weaknesses of your best policy option, including ethical, social, cultural, economic, and environmental impacts.