Problem:
Please reply friendly in two paragraphs to the writer of this post
The debate about women in the Middle East became very heated after Egyptian-American journalist Mona Eltahawy wrote her famous article "Why Do They Hate Us?". In it, she argued that Arab women suffer from deep oppression caused by both culture and religion. Her words shocked many people, especially because she demanded not only political revolutions but also "social and sexual revolutions" to give women real equality. Some people agreed with her bold statements, but others believed she exaggerated and gave a negative image of Arab men and Islam. Journalist Mehdi Hasan later hosted a debate to discuss whether Arab or Muslim societies are truly patriarchal by nature or if this is just a wrong generalization.
During the debate, many important themes were discussed. One of them was about whether Islam itself is to blame for gender inequality, or if the problem comes from cultural traditions. Some progressive voices argued that Islam, when understood correctly, actually supports women's rights. Others said that the way religion is used by men in power often limits women's freedom. Another issue was the way Western media sometimes uses these discussions to create stereotypes, portraying Muslim men as cruel and Muslim women as helpless. This shows that the problem is not only about gender but also about politics, power, and how the Middle East is represented in the world.
In another discussion, writer Isobel Coleman connected women's rights to economic development. She explained that no country can move forward if it ignores half of its population. Closing the gender gap could help Middle Eastern countries increase their GDP and improve their future. She also mentioned that many Muslim women are working within Islamic systems, not outside them, to bring change. For them, religion can be a source of empowerment, not just oppression. Coleman also warned about the role of media, saying that both Western and Muslim media can create false images about women - for example, some Muslim media portray Western women as anti-family, while Western media often see Muslim women only as victims.
Coleman highlighted that women's rights in the Middle East are often confused with Western ideas of feminism, which makes many people reject them. Still, there are many signs of progress: more girls in universities, higher literacy rates, and women becoming more active in public life. She also said that international support, like educational programs and debates, can help, but real change must come from inside these societies.
After the 2011 Egyptian revolution, people expected real freedom and equality, especially for women who had played a strong role in protests. But Coleman explained that the results were mixed. While women became more visible and active, their political participation stayed low, and many of their rights were still ignored. Deeply rooted patriarchal traditions, social pressure, and problems like sexual harassment continued to limit women's progress. Coleman insisted that Islam itself is not the reason behind this, but rather some conservative interpretations that justify inequality. She called for more progressive voices that use religion to empower, not control, women.
Economically, Coleman said that when women are excluded from the workforce, the country's development and stability are affected. In Egypt, as in other Middle Eastern countries, including women in the economy could bring huge benefits. She also mentioned that both local NGOs and international groups can support women through education and reform programs. However, the most important change must come from within the society itself, through awareness, courage, and persistence.
In conclusion, I think Mona Eltahawy's article was provocative, but it started an important conversation. Even if some of her words were too harsh, she made people face uncomfortable truths. At the same time, I agree with voices like Coleman who believe that change should come from inside the culture, not by rejecting it. Women in the Middle East are not weak victims, they are strong, educated, and creative. They are already transforming their societies step by step. The real challenge is to balance tradition, religion, and modernity in a way that allows both men and women to share equality, respect, and hope for a better future. Need Assignment Help?