Maggie Gallagher asserts that there are two basic view of marriage: that of a "public bond and sexual institution" and "as a private emotional relationship." She ultimately claims that gay marriage arises from the second view and that a society which allowed it would not survive. What do you see as her strongest argument for this claim? Which ethical theory do you think that she is using to support her position? Explain.
Evan Wolfson asserts that Maggie Gallagher has not provided sufficient evidence to support her assertion that gay marriage would erode the concept of marriage as a public bond and sexualy institution. What is your objective evaluation of Wolfson's arguments? What ethical theory does he seem to be using to support his position? Explain.
In your opinion, should the state be involved in the regulation of marriage practices? Why? What theory do you use to support your answer?