Case analysis: United States Postal Service (USPS) vs United Parcel Service (UPS)
You will assume a role of an outside consultant and examine the organization and make recommendations to improve the organizational strategies to achieve its goals.
Introduction and background of the case, its products and/or services.
Current organizational structures and culture, current mission, major objectives, and strategies of each organization.
Identify industry trends and its major competitors with market share.
Identify line of products (label them as Cash cow, Star, Dogs and Question mark) ownership of the company (who owns it)
The results of your "situational appraisal" or SWOT analysis (key strengths, weaknesses, threats and opportunities, important environmental trends, industry and competitive analysis, External & Internal Factor Matrix etc.).
Key problems and ranking of those problems.
Alternative organizational strategies considered and evaluation of these strategies.
Your chosen strategy (ies) and why chosen.
Your specific recommendations and plan of action for implementing your strategy.
You will also provide background of the Organization and Strategy of the-Organization, and Competitive Advantage if any.
The basic criteria, which will be used in evaluating project and case analysis are:
Quality of research: thoroughness and accuracy in analyzing and updating information of a project/case
Quality of analysis: effectiveness in applying analytical tools, functional areas of knowledge, etc.
Quality of synthesis: a logical development of ideas and strategic alternatives and analysis of the situation with facts.
Quality of recommendations consistency with situational appraisal: appropriateness of the appraisal and evaluation for management decision, keeping in mind the values, attitudes towards risk and workability or practical application of ideas in solving real organizational problems.