Arbitrability in Major-League Sports
Explain why you agree or disagree with the Supreme Court’s decision to send Garvey’s claim back to the arbitrator.
Garvey argued that the arbitrator rejected the evidence he presented that the Padres wanted to renew his contract because, at a previous hearing, the Padres denied wanting to renew Garvey’s contract. Do you think the arbitrator was right to decide Garvey’s case on evidence from a previous arbitration?