Question: Read your partner's paper and insert track change comments that address the key section in the rubric on the nature of a peer review.
Track Changes
Read and review your partner's paper and use track changes to insert your comments.
Nature of your Peer Review
1. Did the writer clearly state the organizational problem?
2. Is the logical flow of their discussion easy to follow?
3. Did they advance greater understanding of the problem?
4. What was the breadth and depth of the authors that they brought to the discussion?
5. Did they advance plausible solutions to the problem?
6. Did their concluding remarks leave key messages or lessons with you?
7. What did you take away from reading your colleague's applied research project?
8. What are any other insights that you discovered?
9. What suggestions do you have for your colleague with regard to their competency in research writing?