Discussion Post: Methods of Measuring and Evaluating Existing Measures
The center point of research studies is the body of data collected to answer the research question. These data must be measured, which is the act of taking an abstract concept (e.g., depression, anger, etc.), sorting them out and quantifying them in some cohesive way in order to construct meaning-but how can you measure something that is not easily quantifiable?
Choosing an appropriate measurement tool requires consideration of a number of different issues including reliability, validity, appropriateness for use with a specific group or culture, availability, and potential cost. Sometimes, social workers will attempt to create their own set of questions to tap into or measure a concept. This may appear to be an easy thing to do; however, writing questions to measure a phenomenon is more challenging than it would seem. For example, how do we know it measures what we want it to measure? In the first discussion this week, you will have the opportunity to create your own questions to measure a phenomenon of your interest. In the second discussion, you will compare the measure you created with an existing instrument that measures the same phenomenon.
To prepare: Choose one phenomenon or issue that a client may be dealing with (for example, depression, anxiety, or family conflict). Consider how you would evaluate the client's progress in this area. Create questions with response options that would capture this phenomenon or client issue.
1) Identify the phenomenon you would measure and explain how you conceptualize this phenomenon.
2) Provide at least 3 questions you would use to measure this phenomenon and explain how these questions operationalize the phenomenon.
3) Define reliability in 2-3 sentences and give one example of how you would establish reliability for the questions you created.
4) Define validity in 2-3 sentences and give one example of how you would establish validity for the questions you created.
5) Create a measurement plan to assess the phenomenon.
a) Describe the methodology you would use to collect data using your measurement tool (your method for acquiring this research data).
b) Explain the advantages and disadvantages of your choices.
You considered how you might create an instrument for measuring a phenomenon or client issue. For this Discussion, choose and evaluate an existing instrument to measure the concept you identified. Consider how you would compare your original measurement to the existing measurement.
Post a brief explanation of the existing measurement instrument that you identified. Then, compare your original measurement approach to the existing instrument. Next, explain how you would revise or replace your original measurement plan. Finally explain the advantages and/or disadvantages of using existing instruments for measurement. Please use the Learning Resources to support your answer.
The response must include a reference list. One-inch margins, double-space, Using Times New Roman 12 pnt font and APA style of writing and citations.