Mr. Ramchandran is the Chief Executive of ABC Limited, recently it was decided by the Board to Directors that it would be profitable for the corporation to set up a separate Marketing department. Mr. Ramchandran has been directed to pick up a person who he feels is capable of heading the departmental. And then putting this person in charge of getting the department on its feet. After considering a number of good men Mr. Ramchandran has narrowed the field down to two possible choices: Rajesh Mehta and Pramod Kumar.
Rajesh Mehta encompasses a good track record with the company. He was hired eight years ago, and through the years he has shown a good deal of drive and initiative in all of his endeavors. He is an aggressive young man and has received the nickname of 'go-getter' in his department. However Mehta seems to be more concerned at times with ends instead of means,' he is very efficient and is considered a good leader by those who work under him. As one of the worker stated.
Though he can get rough with you at times, you always know where you stand with him, and when you have done a good job, he lets you know it." Mehta is as well credited with accepting full responsibility, in all cases, and making quick decisions when action is called for.
Pramod Kumar has been with the company for eleven years. He is well admired by all in his Department and his work is first rate. Kumar's leadership style differs from Mehta’s in that Kumar is not as aggressive and quick to act as Mehta. Before Kumar makes a decision, he usually consults others who he feels can contribute further information on a given subject.
This often comprises those who work under him. Those who work under Kumar consider him a good Leader, and state that the atmosphere of participation produced by Kumar really encourages their utmost individual output while on the job. This can be seen by the production increase which soon occurred when Kumar became the head of his work force.
Questions:
a) If you were Mr Ramchandran whom would you choose as the head of the Marketing department? Why?
b) Will you give any weightage to the length of service in the organization? Why?