Question: Lease or Buy decision
Larine Industries wants an airplane available for use by its corporate staff. The airplane that the company wishes to acquire, a Superjet 25, can either be purchased or leased from the manufacturer.
Larine Industries’ cost of capital is 20% and the tax rate is 30%.
The company has made the following evaluation of the two alternatives:
Purchase alternative:
Rand
Purchase cost price 2,550,000
Annual cost of servicing and licensing 27,000
Annual Depreciation 50,000
Repairs:
First three years, per year 9,000
Forth year 15,000
Fifth Year 30,000
The Superjet will be sold after five years. Based on current values, the company would be able to sell it for one third of its original cost at the end of the 5 year period.
Lease Alternative:
If the Superjet 25 is leased, then the company would have to make an immediate deposit of R150 000 to cover any damage during use.
The lease would run for five years, at the end of which time the deposit would be refunded.
The lease would require an annual rental payment of R600 000 at the end of each year. As part of the lease cost, the manufacturer will provide all servicing and repairs.
At the end of the five year period, the plane would revert to the manufacturer, as owner.
Required to do:
Question 1: Calculate the total after-tax cost of the present values of the cash flows associated with each alternative.
Question 2: Which financial alternative would you recommend that the company accept, why?