Mace Manufacturing is in the process of analyzing its
investment decision-making procedures. Two projects evaluated by the firm recently
involved building new facilities in different regions, North and South. The basic
variables surrounding each project analysis and the resulting decision actions are
summarized in the following table.
Basic variables North South
Cost $6 million $5 million
Life 15 years 15 years
Expected return 8% 15%
Least-cost financing
Source Debt Equity
Cost (after-tax) 7% 16%
Decision
Action Invest Don’t invest
Reason 8%. 7% cost 15% , 16% cost
a. An analyst evaluting the North facility expects that the project will be financed by debt that costs the firm 7%. What recommendation do you think this analyst will make regarding the investment opportunity?
b. Another analyst assigned to study the South facility believes that funding for that project will come from the firm’s retained earnings at a cost of 16%. What recommendation do you expect this analyst to make regarding the investment?
c. Explain why the decisions in parts a and b may not be in the best interests of the firm’s investors.
d. If the firm maintains a capital structure containing 40% debt and 60% equity, find its weighted average cost using the data in the table.
e. If both analysts had used the weighted average cost calculated in part d, what recommendations would they have made regarding the North and South facilities?
f. Compare and contrast the analyst’s initial recommendations with your findings in part e. Which decision method seems more appropriate? Explain why.