Writing Assignment: Cash and Receivables
Assignment Goals:
- Obtain research experience in the Accounting Standards Codification
- Obtain experience using SEC filings and the SEC website
- Practice writing concise accounting-related deliverables
Assignment: You may complete the assignment on your own or in a group of two students. (You need to find your own group.)
Background and Requirements:
Before beginning this assignment, go to www.sec.gov → Filings → Company filings search to find the June 30, 2016 10-K for The Madison Square Garden Company. (Recall that the 10-K is filed weeks or even months after the fiscal year end.)
After graduating from the University of Dayton, you joined KPMG and became a team member on The Madison Square Garden Company(the Company) audit engagement. (Note: This company is not the same as "MSG Networks, Inc.") The audit of cash and cash equivalents, as well as receivables, is your responsibility, and your senior (supervisor) on the audit team has asked you to perform research in the FASB's Accounting Standards Codification and write a research memo answering questions on the following accountingissues.
Hint: Make sure you read the first few pages of Item 1. Business in the 10-K to obtain the appropriate background on your client. Similar information can be found in Note 1 to the financial statements. Also, look at the 10-K areas referenced below so that you understand the nature of the issues and can appropriately summarize the background for each issue in your memo. I have not provided all of the details in the prompt, as I would like for you to navigate the 10-K.
Relevant information sources for Issue #1 background:
- Balance sheet in 10-K
- Note 1 to financial statements in 10-K (Accounting policies are usually described in Note 1 or Note 2.)
- Assume MSG's June 30, 2016 cash and cash equivalents balance includes $500,000 of 2-year U.S. Treasury notes purchased by MSG on May 15, 2016 and due on July 15, 2016
$300,000 of 1-year U.S. Treasury notes purchased by MSG on July 15, 2015 And due on July 15, 2016
Issue #1 - Should Madison Square Garden Company include certain U.S. Treasury notes in cash and cash equivalents?
Note: Your response should be based on your research in the codification - not the company's policy. Also, it is not acceptable to copy and paste language from the 10-K. Use your own language in the background.
Relevant information sources for Issue #2 background:
-Balance sheet in 10-K
-Note 1 to financial statements in 10-K (Accounting policies are usually described in Note 1 or Note 2.)
Issue #2 - Should amounts in "restricted cash" be presented as "restricted cash" or "cash and cash equivalents"?
Note: Your response should be based on your research in the codification - not the company's policy. Also, it is not acceptable to copy and paste language from the 10-K. Use your own language in the background.
Relevant information sources for Issue #3 background:
- Balance sheet in 10-K
- Note 12
Issue #3 - Is Madison Square Garden Company required to present related party accounts receivable on a separate line on the balance sheet?
Note: Your response should be based on your research in the codification - not the company's policy. Also, it is not acceptable to copy and paste language from the 10-K. Use your own language in the background.
Relevant information sources for Issue #4 background:
- Note 12 - Related Party Transactions (Other parts of the 10-K could be helpful.)
Issue #4 - Is Madison Square Garden Company required to disclose the names of its related parties?
Note: Your response should be based on your research in the codification, as well as your reading of the 10-K. You do not need to summarize every, single detail in Note 12 in your background, but do use specific examples from Note 12 as illustrations.
Note:The memo will be graded for content, research, and writing. See next pages for additional details on expectations.
Expectations for Writingand Research Assignment:
Acceptable Resources
• You may only use the resources (appropriately cited) mentioned above in this assignment. You do not need to cite the 10-K, but you do need to cite the Accounting Standards Codification.
• The Accounting Standards Codification is available at https://aaahq.org/ascLogin.cfm. (user ID: AAA51174 and Password: 3UsZa3U)
• Knowledge Hub: You may use writing support from the Knowledge Hub for this assignment. In the Knowledge Hub, all UD students can receive free research and writing assistance on any assignment, at any stage of the writing process.
• You must complete the assignment individually or in a group of two, and you may not share answers with students who are not in your group. Using resources other than your textbook and those resources mentioned in this assignment (e.g., classmates who are not in your group, parents, CPA friends, other students' prior course memos, assignments that you find online) is a violation of the Honor Code. See the syllabus and Honor Code to understand implications of completing the assignment using unauthorized assistance.
• It is not appropriate to copy background language directly from this assignment or from the 10-K. Use your own words.
Format
• Prepare a memo using the format in the Appendixattached. An example of a written memo is on Isidore.
• Length: Your write-up should be no more than three pages in length
• Spacing: Single-spaced
• Font size and Style: 12 point Times New Roman
• Margins: One-inch on all sides
• Finishing: Pages should be stapled together.
• Footer: Insert page numbers in the footer.
• Cover Sheet: A cover sheet is not necessary.
• Single or Doubled Sided: Single or double sided printing is acceptable.
• Use the APA format to cite the sources. Citations are not counted as a page.
• An appropriate in-text reference to the ASC is generally in the following format: XXX-XX-XX-XX
• Provide proper citations and references. Keep in mind that your textbook is not an appropriate source to cite in this assignment. References should be to the codification.
Writing(See below for questions to ask yourself when you self-review your memo.)
• Your write-up should be clear, concise, complete, free of spelling and grammatical errors, and professional looking (e.g., no "orphan" headings or subheadings).
• The assignment will be graded on the quality of the writing (see Appendix 2) in addition to the quality of the discussion of the accounting issues.
• Your memorandum should be written in a manner that enables a 3rd party who is independent of the issue to understand the issue, relevant research, and your interpretation of the research.
As you proofread your assignment, consider the following items:
• Would someone unfamiliar with the company and the issues (a 3rd party) be able to understand the issues?
• Would someone unfamiliar with the research you are citing (a 3rd party) be able to understand 1) what you found in the codification and 2) how you arrived at your conclusions? (You are encouraged to include well-cited quotes from the codification.)
• Do your tone and word choice fit your audience and the purpose of the memo (e.g., no contractions, no casual phrases)?
o Do you avoid contractions?
• Is your writing grammatically correct?
o Do you refer to a company as an "it" as opposed to a "they"?
o Do you use "its" (possessive) correctly?
o Do you avoid sentence fragments?
• Is your writing concise and easy to read? (Business memos do not require large words or complex phrases.)
• Does the memo flow from one section to another?
• Do you avoid passive writing?
• Are your conclusions clearly stated?
• Does your research and your analysis lead to the conclusions that you have stated?
Academic Honesty:
Here is some advice to help you avoid plagiarizing:
It is best to express the ideas you use in your own words. In the case of both individual and group work, words or ideas that come from someplace or someone else must be cited: "A good rule of thumb is this: Whenever you consciously borrow any important element from someone else, any sentence, any colorful phrase or original term, any plan or idea-say so, either in a footnote, bibliography, or parenthesis" (from "Academic Honesty in the Writing of Essays and Other Papers," Carleton College, 1990).
Appendix 1
Memorandum Format
MEMORANDUM
To: The Madison Square Garden Company, Inc. Audit Files
From: Student name
Date: November XX, 2016
Re: Cash and Accounts ReceivableIssues
Background and Facts
Please see examples on Isidore for further ideas on what to include in each section. This section can be a brief overview of the company and a sentence or two that summarizes the purpose of the memo. It is acceptable to state "The purpose of the memorandum is to...."
Issues
Issue 1:Should Madison Square Garden Company include certain U.S. Treasury notes in cash and cash equivalents?
Issue 1: Background
Tip: Make sure a 3rd party (unfamiliar with the issue) can understand the issue at hand and the significance of the issue based on your background
Issue 1: Research and Analysis
Tip: Make sure this section includes 1) what you find in the codification and 2) your interpretation of what you find in the codification and how it applies to MSG and leads to your conclusion.
Issue 2:Should amounts in "restricted cash" be presented as "restricted cash" or "cash and cash equivalents"?
Issue 2: Background
Issue 2: Research and Analysis
Issue 3:Is Madison Square Garden Company required to present related party accounts receivable on a separate line on the balance sheet?
Issue 3: Background
Issue 3: Research and Analysis
Issue 4:Is Madison Square Garden Company required to disclose the names of its related parties?
Issue 4: Background
Issue 4: Research and Analysis
Conclusion
Financial Statement Impacts
In this section, briefly summarize the impact that the above conclusions will have on the financial statement.