Problem:
As a student how will you respond to this classmate, include in text citation, references and questions
I selected the case related to the "Conscience Clause" legislation, such as Tennessee's House Bill 1840, which allows counselors to refuse services based on sincerely held religious beliefs. While this law protects counselors' freedom of conscience, it raises significant ethical concerns related to client welfare, access to care, and cultural responsiveness. From an ethical standpoint, the primary dilemma lies in balancing counselor autonomy with the obligation to place clients' needs first. Need Assignment Help?
The ACA Code of Ethics (2014) provides clear guidance. Section A.4.b (Personal Values) states that counselors must be aware of their own values and avoid imposing them on clients. Additionally, A.11.b (Values-Based Referral) emphasizes that referrals should not be made solely to avoid working with clients whose values, identities, or beliefs differ from the counselor's. Refusing services to clients based on religious differences-particularly when those differences involve marginalized identities-risks discrimination and harm.
The ASERVIC Spiritual and Religious Competencies further stress the importance of respecting clients' spiritual beliefs while maintaining professional responsibility and cultural humility. As a culturally responsive counselor, ethical practice requires self-reflection, consultation, and continued competence rather than avoidance. While conscience clauses may be legally permissible, ethically counselors must prioritize beneficence, nonmaleficence, and equitable access to counseling services, ensuring personal beliefs do not interfere with client care.