--%>

Federal fiscal stimulus in 2009

Question:

Was the stimulus package passed in 2009 as success?  In answering this question the focus should be the articles on the syllabus, but you should also include opinions of other commentators.   Your answer should also describe why coming to a clear conclusion on this issue is difficult.

Answer:

To start with, the federal fiscal stimulus in 2009 was not as big as it could have been, and as it seems to naked eyes. The federal stimulus was accompanied by a spending cut by the state and local bodies. This, in effect, led to a very small resultant increase in the federal spending.

To discuss the performance of the economy after the stimulus, we have the data to show how the economy is performing. So the FOMC report concludes that there has been an increase in unemployment, a fall in household consumption expenditure, housing sector is still to recover, and the nonresidential structure sector is also in a bad shape. To add to the problems, inflation rate is high due to the high prices of the essential commodities. More so importantly, the tax cuts which were supposed to induce the households to increase their spending, and hence increase the aggregate demand, have mostly failed in their mission. So, overall we may that the economy is still in a bad shape and it may seem easy to assume that the fiscal stimulus has failed to revive the economy.

However, there is something to ponder about here. What would have been the state of the economy had the fiscal stimulus not been provided? Would it have been the same, better or worse? It is true that the tax cuts of 2008 induced only 25% of the households to increase their consumption, and the ARRA stimulus tax cuts were associated with only 13% of households increasing their consumption, nevertheless, there was an increase in the consumption and hence aggregate demand. Households are supposed to smoothen out their consumption rather than acting abruptly to a tax cut. But the point under consideration is that had these tax cuts not taken place, wouldn't the households' and overall economic expenditure had been even lower? The answer is yes. There might have been a downward spiral of declining aggregate demand and spending. The stimulus at least brought some kind of relief.

Therefore, three things come to fore. First, the full gains of the stimulus were not realized due to a simultaneous cut back by state governments. Second, the gains from the stimulus are not as big as expected and the economy is still in a state of uncertainty. Third, the situation could have been even worse in the case of absence of stimulus, however, it this assertion cannot be tested easily.

   Related Questions in Macroeconomics

  • Q : Analyzing number of event that

    How can we analyze the number of event that influences the market?

  • Q : Moentary policy a restrictive monetary

    a restrictive monetary policy is designed to shift the

  • Q : FX rates In June 2005, a Big Mac sold

    In June 2005, a Big Mac sold for 6,000 pesos in Colombia and $3.00 in the United States. The exchange rate in June 2005 was 2,300 pesos per dollar. So, on Big Mac purchasing power parity grounds the Colombian peso was

  • Q : Explain Tax rate increase. A change in

    A change in tax rate changes the IS equation, LM equation remaining the same. Let same, let us suppose that the government raises the tax rate from 20 percent to 25 percent<

  • Q : What is multiplier Multiplier : The

    Multiplier: The Multiplier is the ratio of change in income by the change in investment. Multiplier (k) = ΔY/ΔI

  • Q : Net revenue when price increases Net

    Net revenue for Macho Man fake mustaches increases after the price raised from $5 to $7, pointing that demand faced by Macho Man was: (i) Relatively elastic. (ii) Relatively inelastic. (iii) Unitarily elastic. (iv) Perfectly inelastic. (v) Perfectly e

  • Q : Problem on law of diminishing marginal

    According to law of diminishing marginal utility, the longer that Lee and Chris kiss: (i) the less invested each will be in ongoing this relationship. (ii) The nearer they are to reaching their joined production possibilities frontier. (iii) The more

  • Q : Definition of surplus Definition of

    Definition of surplus: It is a condition in which quantity supplied is more than quantity demanded. To remove the surplus, producers will minimize the price till the market reaches to equilibrium.

  • Q : Market imperfection associated with

    Question: This assignment in Economics, deals with macro-economics. An essay on Market imperfection associated with negative externalities. According to Economics, perfect markets would require an "invisible hand" to allocate all the resources to be a

  • Q : IMF? In saying that the present system

    In saying that the present system of floating exchange rates is managed we mean that: IMF officials determine exchange rates on a day-to-day basis. countries that allow their exchange rate to move freely will lose their borrowing privileges with the IMF. the value of any IMF member's currency